Stepping Up to the Plate: Navigating MLB The Show 23’s Difficulty Levels

Test your baseball skills with MLB The Show 23 difficulty levels. Adjust the challenge to your liking and compete against AI opponents like never before.

Challenge yourself with MLB The Show 23 difficulty levels

If you’re new to the diamond-studded world of MLB The Show, or even a returning veteran, you might be a tad bewildered about what difficulty level to start with. The multiple options can make it feel as if you’re staring down an intimidating pitcher, unsure of whether to swing for the fences or play it safe. Fear not, dear gamers, as we’re here to break down the knuckleball of MLB The Show 23’s difficulty levels and ensure you’re never caught off guard by a nasty curveball!

TL;DR: Fast Facts for the Ninth-Inning Players

  • The most popular difficulty level in MLB The Show 22 was All-Star, chosen by about 35% of players.
  • MLB The Show 23 features five difficulty levels: Rookie, Veteran, All-Star, Hall of Fame, and Legend, each providing a unique level of challenge and realism.
  • The higher the difficulty, the more the game rewards skill and strategy, making it a truly immersive baseball experience.

Understanding MLB The Show 23’s Difficulty Levels: A Detailed Breakdown

The first step to becoming a baseball legend in MLB The Show 23 is to understand the various difficulty levels. This game aims to cater to a broad range of players, from baseball rookies to seasoned gaming pros. Each of the five difficulty levels brings its own unique challenges, rewards, and sense of accomplishment.

Rookie: The Perfect Starting Point

Rookie level is ideal for those just beginning their journey in MLB The Show 23. The gameplay mechanics are more forgiving, and there’s plenty of room for error, making it the perfect training ground for newcomers. Pitches arrive slower and have less movement than any other difficulty, each ramping up the velocity and movement.

Veteran: Turning Up the Heat

Veteran level steps up the game a notch, giving players a taste of the challenges to come while still providing a safety net for those still learning the ropes. At this level, mastering the fundamental mechanics of the game becomes essential for success.

All-Star: Where the Real Game Begins

All-Star is the most popular difficulty level in MLB The Show, and for a good reason. Here, the gameplay strikes a balance between challenging and accessible, demanding more skill from players while still offering an enjoyable gaming experience.

Hall of Fame: A Test for the Skilled

At the Hall of Fame level, MLB The Show 23 starts throwing some curveballs. The AI becomes more formidable, and each game becomes a test of strategy, patience, and skill. Only the most experienced players dare to venture into this level of challenge.

Legend: The Ultimate Challenge

The Legend level is not for the faint of heart. It offers the most realistic and challenging gameplay experience in MLB The Show 23, rewarding strategy, skill, and a deep understanding of baseball’s intricate mechanics. However, it is recommended to practice on Legend difficulty, particularly hitting. Are you ready to become a legend?

Choosing the Right Difficulty Level for You: Insider Tips

One of the best aspects of MLB The Show 23 is its flexibility, allowing you to choose a difficulty level that best matches your skill and experience. It’s important to remember that the game is meant to be enjoyable, so don’t stress if you need to start at a lower level. As you gain experience and sharpen your skills, you can gradually move up the difficulty ladder, ultimately reaching the Legend level if you so desire.

Conclusion: Making Your MLB The Show 23 Experience Legendary

No matter which difficulty level you choose in MLB The Show 23, remember that the ultimate goal is to have fun. Whether you’re swinging for the fences on Rookie or outmaneuvering opponents on Legend, the game offers a rich, immersive baseball experience that’s hard to beat.


Can I change the difficulty level mid-game in MLB The Show 23?

Yes, you can change the difficulty level at any point in the game’s settings menu. However, keep in mind that changing the difficulty may affect the amount of XP and rewards you receive.

What’s the best difficulty level for beginners in MLB The Show 23?

The Rookie difficulty level is the best for beginners, as it offers a forgiving gameplay experience that allows new players to learn the ropes and understand the game’s mechanics.

Does playing on a higher difficulty level give more rewards?

Yes, playing on a higher difficulty level in MLB The Show 23 will give you more XP and better rewards (like in March to October). Remember, the gameplay will also be more challenging.


Russell, R. (2023). “A Deep Dive into MLB The Show 23’s Difficulty Levels”. MLB The Show Blog.
“MLB The Show 23 Difficulty Levels Explained”. (2023). GameSpot.
“MLB The Show 23: Complete Guide and Walkthrough”. (2023). IGN.

This post is also available in:

Rate Our Content: 1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (5 votes, average: 4.00 out of 5)